Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube Rss

Archives - Public Discourse

Catholic school tech use

When It Comes to Technology, Catholic Schools Can Lead by Example 

By
If 1:1 programs are not a particular benefit to character development, spiritual development, or the Church’s care for the poor, the argument for their pervasiveness among most Catholic schools appears weak at best and imprudent and negligent at worst.
ICE

What Can ICE Learn from the Byzantine Migration Enforcement?  

By
To what extent can migration be legitimately regulated and enforced, and under what circumstances may migrants already residing within a country be returned to their place of origin? 
Bible

Parsing Pluralism: In Defense of Hopeful Realism 

By
Contrary to some critical readers, the liberal democracy that Hopeful Realism can affirm is far from neutral.
online sports gambling

A Modest Proposal to Rein in Sports Gambling 

By
Requiring sportsbooks to treat all customers alike would satisfy liberal values of nondiscrimination and freedom while satisfying the socially conservative impulse to rein in a destructive industry.   
family of three

Will Germany Lift Its Surrogacy Ban?  

By
Altruistic surrogacy can avoid the extremes found in its commercial form, such as material exploitation and inhumane contract terms. However, the fundamental problem of surrogacy remains: a child is conceived in the interest of others; the biological mother is merely a means to an end.  
JD Vance

Two Trump VPs, Two Visions 

By
What we need is not more polarization, but more earnest engagement.   
flip phone

The Case for Technological Foot-Dragging 

By
Technology has always claimed our treasure, but as it increasingly claims our attention also, the need for resistance takes on a spiritual dimension.
Yale

God and Man at Yale at 75 

By
In a postmodern and increasingly siloed society that now lacks any universal moral codes or even reference points, it isn’t clear that the value of humanity itself can be successfully defended—at Yale or anywhere else.  
James Madison

“Liberty Preserved”: The Foundation of Our Freedom 

By
The Founders understood humanity’s inherent corruption and recognized that both civil and religious liberties rest on the common principle of faithfulness to God. If we lose sight of fidelity to God, we risk losing the moral foundation on which our liberties are built.  
factory workers

The Best Protection for Workers is the Market

By
The lesson here is as simple as it is profound. The market, meaning the right to quit and get another job on better terms, is the best protection for the worker.
therapy

Trauma’s Triumph, Trauma’s Traps 

By
Trauma-informed care promises to reveal and resolve the connection between present aberrant behavior and past mistreatment by others. But its political corollary valorizes victimhood, and its questionable logic has the potential to trap rather than free those who suffer from past wounds.  
Federal Reserve

The Nation That Cried, “Debt!” 

By
What are the ethical issues surrounding government debt? This is a good time to start taking that question seriously.
religious freedom

The Friendship That Changed International Religious Freedom for America and the World 

By
A friendship begun in 1985, forged in shared Christian faith and encounters with human misery driven by animus toward religion, would become the ground on which a historic legacy would be built.
abandoned soviet building

Postliberalism’s Rebellion Against Reality 

By
It is good to oppose communism. It is not good to oppose communism out of support for clerical fascism. 
China

Why China Will Never Democratize 

By
China’s rise forces scholars and policymakers to confront an uncomfortable reality: that modernity no longer belongs to the West.
SCOTUS

Libel and Law-Office History 

By
American self-government has not benefited from two generations of the Sullivan standard. 
grave

Whatever Happens at all, Happens as It Should 

By
There is something severe in this kind of wisdom, but also merciful. We cannot command that the past return what it has rightfully taken. We cannot bargain with time, or exempt ourselves, or those we love from the common fate of all mankind. We can only determine what shall be made of the days that remain to us. Stat sua cuique dies (“each has his appointed day”) as Jupiter spoke in Virgil’s Aeneid, reflecting on the mortality of mankind. That appointed day comes for each of us; what remains within our power is not to escape the limits of our nature, but to determine how we shall live within them. 
smartphone

The Bookshelf: A Post-Literate Age? 

By
The New Dark Ages, which I hope will be widely read, is a brief, brisk, and persuasive book about the damage our screen life is doing to our social and political life. He puts the matter starkly in his introduction: “As reading fades I believe that we may find ourselves facing a post-literate future that resembles the pre-literate past: mystical, tribal, and autocratic.”
Robots and job interview

The Virtue of Letting Skills Die 

By
AI will make many cognitive techniques obsolete, and preserving them for their own sake would mistake difficulty for formation. Schools and workplaces should instead preserve or rebuild the learning functions that cultivate judgment, prudence, and human agency. 
Sartre

Theory’s Rise and Fall  

By
Theory, though it blazed brightly for a time, was doomed to burn out. It simply could not give a deep account of the human condition and of those things that are most important to being human—e.g., love, altruism, friendship, gratitude—that fully reflect the human experience. 
Talmud

America Saved the Jews. Can the Jews Save America? 

By
Americans are fighting over who decides what’s true. Jews once argued for truth itself. Can Jews teach America how to argue yet remain united? 
political parties

A Democrat’s Ideological Journey on Abortion 

By
So long as the pro-life movement is part of the GOP coalition, the attractiveness of the pro-life message is affected by the attractiveness of the GOP. And it’s hard to grow the pro-life tent if the pro-life movement is bound up with a hard-right GOP that is repellent to centrist and center-left voters. 
Odyssey

Homer Against the Attention Economy  

By
What modern culture discards as redundant, the ancient poets understood as the foundation of memory, identity, and human connection. 
Constitution

The American Pope and the American Constitution 

By
In his day, Brownson advocated for a “long-term, multi-pronged rediscovery of the true Constitution,” an ordered liberty founded on a balance of unity in diversity based on natural law and the pursuit of the common good. He challenges us to “rediscover the true Constitution.” Now would be an appropriate time to follow his advice.