The Irish Health Service Executive (HSE) recently confirmed that “transgender men who have given birth can access statutory maternity leave.” This was never in doubt. A “transgender man” is biologically a woman and statutory maternity leave in Ireland attaches to any “pregnant employee,” but the agency issued a clarification anyway. Since 2015, a woman can legally certify herself as male under Irish law and this entitles her to all the consequences of that purported reality. But the law does not help her escape her need to recover and bond with her child after giving birth. 

There used to be two checks on an Irish law before it could be implemented: a standard above the law—natural law—against which the law could be measured, and a legislature that measured it. Ireland has abandoned the first as a matter of jurisprudence and the second as a matter of habit. What remains is popular will, and popular will implements nothing. Agencies and courts fill the vacuum with guidance, regardless of whether it is warranted. Americans have spent decades arguing about how much interpretive power agencies should hold. Ireland arrived at an answer without the argument. 

The question is not whether the HSE guidance was correct, but why anyone thought it was necessary. The entitlement was never in doubt. What was in doubt was whether Irish law still means what its words describe. A law that changes the meaning of basic human terms like “man” and “woman” creates doubt beyond what it actually touches. Edmund Burke once wrote that circumstances “give in reality to every political principle its distinguishing color and discriminating effect.” A legislature that writes laws from principle without considering any circumstances produces laws that cannot be enforced. An agency or a court must figure out how to implement these laws downstream. 

Legislating to Principle, Not Circumstance 

The Gender Recognition Act of 2015 allows any unmarried adult to self-declare a gender and obtain all the consequences of the associated sex. A biological man applies to be recognized as a woman and everything, from an “F” on the passport to access to private female spaces, follows the new gender recognition certificate. No supporting evidence is required in this process. In fact, the bill that went through pre-legislative scrutiny required a medical practitioner to certify the application; the bill that passed did not. The requirement remained for minors who wish to apply for a court order to obtain a certificate, but only to certify that the child freely chooses to apply, not for a medical opinion. The Seanad, Ireland’s upper house, exists to revise what the lower house sends it. Senator Gerard Craughwell, who supported the bill through that chamber, admitted in 2023 that the effects of the law horrified him, tweeting at one point, “Has the entire country gone stark raving mad?” 

Start your day with Public Discourse

Sign up and get our daily essays sent straight to your inbox.

The confusion extends to the prison system, where uncertain implementation of the law has led to abuse. In 2023, a report by the visiting committee of Dóchas Centre, a women’s prison in Dublin, called for the creation of a clear transgender policy for Irish prisons. This is not because the committee is wrapped up in gender ideology; rather, there is no guidance on how to appropriately apply the Gender Recognition Act to prisoners. Barbie Kardashian’s case is an example of ideology having no workable implementation. Born Gabriel Alejandro Gentile, this man successfully applied for a gender recognition certificate—recognizing him as a woman—in 2020. In 2023, he was convicted of threatening to torture, rape, and murder his mother, adding to an extensive list of prior offenses. Due to his self-declaration under the Gender Recognition Act, he was placed in a women’s prison. Soon after, he was accused of threatening a female prisoner and a prison officer while in custody. Although he was acquitted of those specific charges, he was moved to a men’s prison in 2025, where he was segregated from the rest of the population because he was legally a woman. In July 2025, the Council of Europe’s Committee on the Prevention of Torture found that he was held in “dungeon-like” conditions with minimal light and ventilation, in solitary confinement for twenty-three hours each day. By following the Act’s directive to consider this man a woman, the prison system first endangered a female prisoner and a prison officer, then subjected the man they sought to accommodate to conditions so bad they drew a supranational rebuke. In its haste to validate self-identification, the state stripped the dignity of both Kardashian and his victims. 

This fatal flaw in Ireland’s approach to policymaking extends beyond gender ideology. In 2021, the government launched a three-year plan to provide “own-door” accommodation for every asylum seeker within three years (ignoring the preexisting homelessness crisis, which has seen the number of homeless in Ireland quintuple since 2014). The political principle was clear, but no circumstance for implementing it ever materialized. Asylum seekers lined the streets, living in tents provided by the state, outside the International Protection Office to await their promised housing.  

In March 2024, the government shelved the original plan. Six weeks later, it deployed bulldozers to remove and destroy more than 200 tents where the asylum seekers had been living. The Irish Supreme Court is currently weighing the state’s liability for breaching the European Union’s Charter of Fundamental Rights for nearly 3,000 asylum seekers. Previously, a lower court awarded damages of €6,000 (7,000)and€9,500(11,200) to two asylum seekers under the EU Reception Conditions Regulations. The same pattern is visible here as it is with gender recognition: the state legislates a certain principle, makes no concrete plan for implementing it effectively, and delegates the cleanup operation to agencies or courts. 

The point here has little to do with Ireland’s specific policies relating to gender or immigration, and more with Irish lawmakers’ failure at the business of lawmaking. But this is not just a failure of one generation of “woke” politicians; it’s built into the very system that creates the laws, and it has two parts. Jurisprudence removed the standard against which a statute could be measured, leaving popular approval as the only test for what may be enacted. The parliament that enacts it stopped applying the second test: whether the thing can be done at all. 

The Fall of Natural Law 

Natural law jurisprudence in Ireland has dramatically shifted in recent decades. Following guidance from Pope Pius XI in Quadregesimo Anno, the Irish constitution explicitly states that the family has rights “antecedent and superior to all positive law,” and jurisprudence initially followed this principle. The 1965 ruling in Ryan v. Attorney General established the doctrine of “unenumerated rights,” recognizing that rights not mentioned in the Constitution could be derived from natural law. McGee v. Attorney General (1974) addressed the same issue—with a similar outcome—as Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) did in the United States. Where Griswold used penumbras and emanations to find a right to privacy among previously established rights, Ryan and McGee derived it from natural law: the family has unenumerated privacy rights that cannot be invaded by the state. This doctrine began to crumble in the 1990s. In 1995, Ireland’s Chief Justice Liam Hamilton held that the Constitution is superior to natural law, paving the way for popular constitutional amendments constrained only by the appetite of the public through referenda (Re Article 26 and the Abortion Information Bill (1995)). On the face of it, Ireland seems refreshingly democratic, putting the instruments of power in the hands of the people. In reality, this ruling facilitated ideological politicians with little understanding of good governance rising to power, pointing to the “will of the people” every time they passed a bad law. 

The Rise of Unnatural Law 

What followed was decades of legislation and constitutional amendments ultimately rejecting natural law: the redefinition of marriage including same-sex unions (2015) and no-fault divorce (1995, 2019); the liberalization of abortion all the way to enshrining it as a constitutional right (2018); and the declaration that the state, not necessarily a child’s parents, will be the final arbiter of a child’s best interest (2012), significantly weakening the “antecedent and superior” status of the family. The superior law of the land was once governed by natural law; now it is governed by whatever side deployed the best marketing campaign to voters. 

Importantly, the Irish legislature has abdicated its duty to good governance to such an extent that the public has had to provide the check. In 2024, the government proposed two further constitutional amendments to popular vote: one to remove the word “mother” entirely from the Constitution and another to grant family rights to any “durable relationships” beyond marriage. The precise definition of the phrase was explicitly left to the courts to define after passage. The Electoral Commission admitted that receiving a Christmas card as a couple could qualify them as a family under the law. The electorate, by then the only remaining check on Ireland’s failing lawmaking practices, refused both, voting against “durable relationships” by 68 percent, and the deletion of “mother” by 74 percent—the largest “no” vote the state has ever recorded. Clearly, lawmaking had reached a level of failure that even the popular will could no longer support. This is the same failure that caused Senator Craughwell to regret his own chamber’s lack of revision. It is the same failure that prompted the HSE to clarify that “transgender men” could take leave after giving birth. 

The business of governing did not stop as legislators embraced this positivist approach to lawmaking; it merely migrated to the HSE, the prison service, the courts enforcing European Directives, and other unelected bureaucracies. For all its flaws, American law’s Chevron doctrine was a fleshed-out legal doctrine that received serious argument and consideration before being overturned in the 2024 Loper Bright decision. In Ireland, it has become the default precisely because nobody is willing to name the problem, let alone reverse it. The rise of unnatural law in Ireland is not a contested doctrine subject to rigorous debate. It’s the failure of a parliament committed to ideological activism instead of the rule of law. 

Like the rest of the West, the U.S. and Ireland plunged into the culture wars. Abortion, marriage, gender ideology, and immigration are contested issues. The difference is that the United States has a structure in place to identify and debate the issues over time. Persuasion campaigns can win the argument, but the institutions still must build the thing. The Irish parliament retains the ceremony of passing laws but the responsibility of testing them against reality—once checked by natural law—is deferred: a referendum can only answer the question the legislature presents, and the agencies and courts must figure out what the answer means. An agency clarifying a statute that nobody asked it to touch is not a curiosity but a constitutional fact. When the elected representatives decline to say what their own laws require, the rule of law becomes the rule of whoever is left to figure it out. 

 Image licensed via Adobe Stock.