A few years ago, I started getting ads for an app called Peanut. It marketed itself as a tool to connect mothers who wanted to exchange advice and support. When I finally caved and looked it up, I discovered it worked more like Bumble (with whom it shares a co-founder): you get a menu of people in your local community (in this case specifically, moms), and you start swiping right or left.  

As an elder Gen-Zer, I’m very much in the Tinder generation. The concept of commodifying sex through “dating” apps that are really mostly used for hookups saddens me, but it doesn’t shock me. Naively, I thought commodifying friendship was less likely to take off: then more such apps started popping up on my social media. Bumble added the Bumble BFF feature specifically for platonic relationships; Cosmopolitan launched Club Cosmo, which, despite its promise to help you “vet new besties,” seems to be largely about accessing special promotions and giveaways. And just earlier this fall, we got Caeli, which promises to help you “build your village” by crowdsourcing wisdom, connecting you to fellow moms, and giving you access to an AI chat based on the work of a team of experts in parenting, fertility, and family counseling. If you’re from the UK, think Mumsnet but on steroids.  

Whatever you make of these new applications of technology to connect people in need of true friendship, it all sounds rather wholesome when compared to the plot of Klara and the Sun, written by Nobel Prize winner Kazuo Ishiguro and now adapted for the big screen by Taika Waititi of Jojo Rabbit and Thor: Ragnarok fame.  

Klara is an AF, that is, an artificial friend: a solar-powered humanoid robot. Like all AFs, Klara was created for the purpose of easing human loneliness. In Ishiguro’s imagined future, children are largely educated at home, by online tutors. Unsurprisingly, the novel was written around the time of the COVID-19 lockdowns. Parents who can afford it put their children through a process of “lifting,” aka genetic enhancement, which makes them academically brilliant, but also makes them vulnerable to an unexplained illness. With weaker immune systems than their peers, “lifted” children are incredibly isolated. Josie, whose older sister Sal has already died after lifting, has no opportunities for socialization, except with her “unlifted” childhood friend, Rick. Josie chooses Klara, and the two form a close bond.  

Yet this is, quite plainly, not a friendship by any definition of the concept. Aristotle wrote in the Nicomachean Ethics that the only true form of friendship is one in which both individuals wish the good of the other in a disinterested way. St. Augustine characterized it in his Confessions as a shared love of God. In The Four Loves, C. S. Lewis famously contrasted the image of the lovers, who gaze at each other, fully absorbed by the other person, to that of the friends, who instead look together at a mutual interest or goal, standing next to, rather than in front of, each other.  

Start your day with Public Discourse

Sign up and get our daily essays sent straight to your inbox.

What all three understandings of friendship have in common is that they have voluntary reciprocity at their core. I want to be your friend not because I expect you to wish my good, but because I wish your good. You want to be my friend not because you demand that I wish your good, but because you desire my happiness. When the goodwill is unforced but mutual, a true friendship bond is created. 

This is not to deny the good of other kinds of bonds. There can never be true friendship between a parent and their infant child, for instance, yet the relationship is no less beautiful and significant. Married couples often inhabit a hybrid relationship, where throughout the decades of their marriage the relationship of lovers (i.e., being absorbed by each other) and friendship (i.e., looking at a common project) exist simultaneously yet alternate taking precedence in different seasons of life. 

We’ve heard again and again, rightly, that the Sexual Revolution liquefied the marriage bond by transforming romantic relationships from this kind of mutual goodwill into a utilitarian transaction based on the exchange of goods, i.e., sexual pleasure. In Klara and the Sun, Ishiguro explores instead what happens when we commodify platonic relationships with the aid of AI.  

Buying an artificial friend for a lonely kid might seem, instinctively, less repulsive than, say, hiring a sexbot, but the logic behind it is frighteningly similar. Klara is supposed to act like a friend, but she is treated as a servant. In the most chilling moment of the novel, Klara discovers that Josie’s mother, already grieving in case Josie’s illness results in her death, has arranged for an AF lookalike of her daughter to be made. Josie’s mother seeks the consolation of a Josie lookalike, but that desire inherently dehumanizes her actual daughter, who is still alive and who needs her own mother to tell her that she is precious and loved unconditionally. The irreplaceability of the human person is, at its core, the thesis of the novel. 

But what about Waititi’s new interpretation? The film has been panned by UK critics in publications that span the political spectrum. Everyone seems to agree it’s a badly conceived rendition that relies too heavily on portraying Klara as the robot version of the “manic pixie dream girl” trope. It’s been called “contrived,” “infantile,” and a “betrayal” of Ishiguro’s “quiet, meditative vision,” largely due to the fact that Waititi steers the tone of the film toward something much more darkly funny. I didn’t mind that. The film has interesting retro-futuristic visuals; the script is occasionally saccharine, but even the most sentimental moments are saved by competent acting. I didn’t even mind the change from Ishiguro’s signature contemplative narration to Waititi’s signature surrealist satire. Adaptations are after all translations, and I think it’s generally better for a translator to create a work of art in its own right rather than trying to please purists.  

Still, the question remains: does Waititi understand what I have argued is at the core of the novel’s meaning, the axiomatic belief that the human person is irreplaceable? Here’s where we get into murky waters. I would say that the film itself—by which I mean the combination of the script and how the actors enacted it—does embrace this premise. There are two moments in particular that suggest this. One is Klara’s reaction to seeing the mechanical birds that Rick, Josie’s only human friend, has made. While Josie keeps trying to find a practical application for Rick’s creation, like military surveillance, Klara is convinced that “There doesn’t need to be a point. I think they’re fine just being birds.” She believes that existence is good in and of itself, which is the opposite of how Josie and her family treat Klara, that is, as a means to the end of “friendship” rather than valuable in her own right.  

The other revealing moment is the scene in which Josie’s mother, having seen in person the AF body of her daughter (which Klara’s consciousness will enter should Josie in fact die), begins to have doubts about the plan. The specialist who’s been working on replacement Josie, Mr. Capaldi, tries to assuage her fears by telling her that he did the same after his own wife died: “There’s nothing special about us. Nothing that can’t be copied or recreated. I can barely tell the difference with my wife.” This moment is not played as tragic or filled by existential dread, but rather, as satirical. Steve Buscemi plays Mr. Capaldi as grotesque, his own replacement wife looking absently on as he claims that he can’t tell the difference between her and his original spouse. There is no possibility of the audience’s hearing this claim about the lack of something “special” in the human person without immediately concluding that we should not agree with it.  

As for Waititi himself, it’s unclear where he stands. In an interview he recently gave about the film, he talks about whether he would want an AF to replace his own children. “The younger me would have thought, ‘Oh, you can’t replace someone special,’” he says. “But the older I get, and the more in love with my kids I get, I think, ‘Oh, eventually I’d believe it was them.’ The human brain is easily adaptable … So I’d definitely consider replacing one of my children … They don’t even have to be dead. I’d just like a version that’s nice to me and doesn’t ask for money.” I’m not sure how seriously we’re meant to take this—probably not very, given Waititi’s famously deadpan Kiwi sense of humour. Still, I wonder if there is a little truth to this. Maybe Waititi would choose the consolation of a replacement child if he lost him or her; maybe he would even enjoy an AF child who is nicer to him than his real kids. Wouldn’t we all be at least a little tempted? 

And when we—real people living in 2026, not characters from a sci-fi novel—search for love and now even friendship through apps that scan for our preferences and dislikes, are we that different from Josie and her mother? Our choices are less extreme, but they exist on a continuum. Are we not treating friendships and romantic relationships like commodities as we swipe left and right, looking for the best fit, for the person who will enrich my life the most? And if that is how we approach human relationships, is there any space left for the kind of mutual goodwill that should be the mark of true friendship?  

When we—real people living in 2026, not characters from a sci-fi novel—search for love and now even friendship through apps that scan for our preferences and dislikes, are we that different from Josie?

 

In many ways, the world of Klara and the Sun is infinitely more sinister than our current reality. But Ishiguro’s story also comes with a warning. It’s easy to treat what we make, in this case a humanoid robot, as less human than ourselves. It should be harder to do so with actual members of our human family, yet we are allowing technology to shape our relationships to become precisely that: dehumanizing. We are quite far down that path already.  

It’s ironic that it should be Klara herself, a non-human, who reminds us how we are meant to treat each other. “Mr. Capaldi believed there was nothing special inside Josie that couldn’t be continued,” Klara tells us in the novel. “He told the Mother he’d searched and searched and found nothing like that. But I believe now he was searching in the wrong place. There was something very special, but it wasn’t inside Josie. It was inside those who loved her.” 

Image licensed via Adobe Stock.